Annonce
Annonce
Annonce
News in english

EDITORIAL: We need a Truth Commission

New revelations again stress the need for a Truth Commission to bring transparency to the Iraq War.

Gem til liste

Do the furious generals in the Pentagon, and our own irate NATO secretary-general, have a point in seriously condemning the massive leak of military documentation about the Iraq War that took place on Saturday?

The international media – led by the New York Times – that decided to pass on and verify the enormous amount of material, do not think so. And any risks there may be, pale compared with the risk of letting the powers that be wage war behind closed doors.

The decision to go to war – and this is not a question of a defensive war – is so grave, and can have such terrible consequences, that it must be able to tolerate full and extensive verification.

This is particularly the case with the Iraq War, which from its inception had no basis in international law. As a result, more than any other recent war led by a coalition of democratic countries, it could only be justified by an eventual, unequivocal success.

Unfortunately, the release of some 400,000 documents confirms that the Iraq War is a conflict involving major human and financial costs and with a highly questionable and uncertain result.

The human cost, calculated in overall loss of life - appears to be even higher than previously thought.

Even worse than that, the torture scandal that was unearthed at Abu Ghraib, is only the top of the iceberg in relation to an even greater moral catastrophe: the United States and its allies, including Denmark, have handed thousands of Iraqis over to even worse and more extreme torture than was the case at Abu Ghraib.

There was an inherent risk that the new Iraqi security forces would carry on Saddam Hussein’s worst traditions. But that does not justify ignoring the risk, not to mention legitimising it oneself by undermining the ban on torture, as was the case during the Bush years.

It is gratifying that so many parliamentarians have reacted so gravely to these revelations. As Obama’s caution in opening legal proceedings shows, it is difficult for democratic politicians to criminalise a policy that their similarly democratically elected predecessors have conducted. Even when it was criminal.

But that does not alter the need to bring transparency to the issue, in order to avoid a repeat.

A Truth Commission, in which those responsible are heard, and the complex in its entirety is exposed, should be the least we can demand. Here in Denmark too.

ts

PolitikenPlus
  • Ur, unisex *Bulbul er navnet på en fugl, en lille fugl med hanekam og et oppustet ego. På samme tid er det også navnet på nattergalen i persisk og indisk poesi.

    Pluspris 2.000 kr. Alm. pris 2.500 kr. Køb
  • Chart | Art Fair Messen blev allerede i sit første år en stor succes med over 11.000 besøgende i den sidste weekend i august 2013.

    Pluspris 75 kr. Alm. pris 100 kr. Køb
  • Bulldog Det var en varm sommerdag i 2006. På benzintanken midt i København holdt en amerikanerbil.

    Pluspris 800 kr. Alm. pris 920 kr. Køb
  • Twin Peaks Bluray Boks David Lynch' legendariske serie er endelig ude i en ultimativ Bluray boks med hele serien, filmen Fire Walk With Me og en masse hidtil uset ekstra materiale.

    Pluspris 440 kr. Alm. pris 500 kr. Køb
  • Håndklæder Håndklæder i bambus kvalitet, 3 stk. i en pakke. Helt lette og fine håndklæder, som også kan brugers som tæpper, dug eller plaid.

    Pluspris 199 kr. Alm. pris 250 kr. Køb