-
POLITIKEN MENER: Bureaukratiet er folkeskolens fjende
-
ANDEKONKURRENCE: Kan du skrive som en ny Walt Disney?
-
BRRRRR...: Her er de koldeste steder på jorden
-
PLUS: 'Drive' på dvd
Pluspris 150 kr.
International partner
International partner
-
12. feb
SYRIA: Arab League to ask UN for peacekeeping force in Syria News Wires
-
12. feb
GREECE: Protesters clash with police during austerity vote ehong
-
12. feb
2012 Africa Cup of Nations: Zambia seek to honour fallen idols against Ivory Coast News Wires, FRANCE 24
-
12. feb
MUSIC: Whitney Houston's life, death and musical legacy Ben MCPARTLAND
-
12. feb
FRENCH POLITICS: For France?s blighted north, a Green path out of crisis Benjamin DODMAN
International partner
-
09. feb
Monti Bans Gifts Worth More Than ?150 WATSON GEORGE GILES
-
08. feb
Snow Plough Graveyard at San Saba WATSON GEORGE GILES
-
07. feb
Volunia, Italy?s Answer to Google WATSON GEORGE GILES
-
06. feb
Spats in the Time of Twitter WATSON GEORGE GILES
-
03. feb
How Daisy Alliance Signed Off Lusi?s Accounts WATSON GEORGE GILES
Nobel laureate - We can't wait for politicians
DER SPIEGEL: The world is gathered in Copenhagen in an effort to reach an agreement to slow global warming. Elinor Ostrom, winner of this year's Nobel prize in economics, spoke with SPIEGEL ONLINE about shared ownership, local action and why we can't sit around waiting for politicians to act.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: The Copenhagen summit is about setting new global rules for how we treat the Earth. But are people willing to change their personal lives accordingly?
Elinor Ostrom: Under the right circumstances, people are willing to accept additional efforts and costs. It all depends on trust that others will also act. Humans have the capacity to engage and see that their own long term future is harmed if they don't change their lifestyles. Under the right circumstances they understand: It's not me against you. It's all of us against ourselves, if we don't act. So trust really is the most important resource.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: How can we generate enough trust so that we all act in concert?
Ostrom: Rules set from the top are not enough. Successful communities often have a few common design principles, monitoring and sanctioning of the participants, for example. They also have conflict resolution mechanisms in place and the people have some authority to make their own rules. Under those circumstances humans can develop some trust in each other -- faith that if they take a costly action that benefits everybody in the long run, others will also invest.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: Why is it less effective if governments establish strict rules from the top down?
Ostrom: Because people will not identify with it. My research has shown that forests managed by local communities are in a far better state than state-run parks, where locals feel left out and officials can be bribed. Let us imagine, we live in a village and have all agreed that none of us is going to be in the forest on Saturday or Sunday, so that we can give the forest time to recreate. If I then see you in the forest when you're not supposed to be, I will probably yell at you. If only the state is in charge, I will just walk on past.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: In your research, you focused on local and regional levels. What makes you think that your solutions would work for the entire planet as well?
Ostrom: Indeed, the global scale is a challenge. Building that kind of knowledge between the different parties is tricky. We need our global leaders to take some of the decisions on a very big level. Here at the summit, those guys are talking to each other and gaining some trust because they meet face to face. But then they go home -- and that's when the real action starts.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: Can money help to build trust between developing nations and industrialized nations?
Ostrom: Maybe, and it is hard to see a climate deal without serious financial commitments. But at the same time, I am very worried and nervous about corruption. If we pour money into a country in which the corruption level is very high, we would be kidding ourselves not to think that some of it will end up in the wrong pockets. At first, a lot of the proposals on the table sound great. But four to six years later, you have a lot of politicians who have money in Swiss bank accounts. What we need are tight rules and controls to ensure that the billions that might be put on the table here are used correctly.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: In other words, an anti-corruption task force, like exists in Indonesia, might be the best environmental protection agency?
Ostrom: Absolutely! If you look at the role corruption plays in giving away forests to big corporations and in looking away if forest protection rules are broken, you will see that bribery is one of the main contributors to environmental destruction.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: Is it possible to save the climate with a single treaty?
Ostrom: One treaty will not solve the problem entirely. This is why I propose a so-called polycentric approach to tackling climate change. We need all levels of human society to work on this to be effective in the long run. Cities, villages, communities and networks of people have been neglected as players.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: What happens if there is no agreement?
Ostrom: We need to get away from the idea that there is only one solution on the global scale. There are many, many levels in between. So we need to take action on smaller levels. If the politicians do not agree in Copenhagen, I would like to embarrass the hell out of them by getting some agreements going where people are doing something -- essentially saying: "We are tired of waiting for you." The city of Freiburg is a very good place to see what that actually means.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: Why Freiburg of all places?
Ostrom: I spend quite a bit of time in Germany and I'm very impressed by some of the local action I see. Local action cannot do it fully, but just think about all the bicycle-paths that they have built there. That is a case where the action of individuals is reducing emissions. At the same time it is a very healthy thing. On Sundays everybody is going to the woods and has a good time on their bikes -- and not in their cars. It's good for your health and for the environment. So everyone should ask himself: Why don't I bike to work and leave the damn car at home or get rid of it entirely?
SPIEGEL ONLINE: Still, such a decentralized approach sounds painfully slow. But we need rapid action if we wish to limit global warming to 2 degrees Celsius.
Ostrom: If we sit here and twiddle our thumbs and wait for these guys up there to make a decision -- that is what I would call painfully slow. Should we just blame the politicians? I am not saying that we can solve it entirely, but we can make significant steps. To some extent we can challenge them. Everyone can contact foolish politicians like some US Congressmen who oppose climate change action by e-mail or phone and let them know that they are acting irresponsibly.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: Why is the US so reluctant to fight climate change?
Ostrom: In the economic emergency we are experiencing, some people think that we cannot afford it. I think it is the other way around, if we don't act now we will run into even greater economic problems in the future. And of course we still have the bad legacy of our previous president, George W. Bush. For eight years, the White House saw the issue as not being important. We did not have American leaders who understood that there is a scientific foundation. Obama has a much higher chance of understanding the science. But even for him it is just damn tough.
SPIEGEL ONLINE: Worries about climate change have slowly resulted in people seeing the Earth's atmosphere as a common good that we all must protect. Where is the next challenge?
Ostrom: The oceans! They are being threatened to an ever greater degree. It is a disaster, a very difficult situation. The fish resources are overexploited and waste, including CO2, is dumped in huge quantities into the ocean. The law of the sea has not been effective at all. A lot of fishing ships act like roving bandits. That's why better ocean governance is one of the top priorities for safeguarding the future.
Interview conducted by Christoph Seidler and Christian Schwägerl
Edited by Julian Isherwood
SKOLE OG UDDANNELSE – Fokus på skolernes fremtid
Læs Politiken hver TIRSDAG BESTIL I DAG
- Få nyhederne gratis i din indbakke hver morgen.
Ekspert: Overenskomst er en gratis omgang
Ekspert kalder industriens overenskomst for et smalt forlig, der ikke vil koste virksomhederne meget.
-
Demonstranter og politi udkæmper voldsomme gadekampe i Athen
-
Musik12. feb. KL. 17.56
Fans massesørger over Whitney Houston
Både Twitter og Facebook flyder over af kærlige mindeord om Whitney Houston.
Denzel Washington fik blåt øje i ny actionfilm
Der er smæk for skillingen både på skærmen og på settet i 'Safe House'.
-
Håndbold12. feb. KL. 18.42
Ansatte raser over kritik efter drab på kollega
Ansatte på bostedet Blåkærgård er kede af det og frustrerede over kritik.
-
Fodbold12. feb. KL. 15.40
Så kom undskyldningen fra Suárez: Jeg begik en fejl, jeg fortryder
Liverpool-spilleren Luis Suárez er på knæ efter skandalen på Old Trafford, hvor han ikke ville give hånd til United-spiller.
-
Danmark12. feb. KL. 14.47
Uheldigt sammenfald tog strømmen i København
Et større strømsvigt ramte tidligere i dag store dele af det centrale København.
Seneste nyt
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 19.38 Arabere vil lave fredsstyrke sammen med FN
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 19.15 Med apps på smartphonen finder du billig benzin
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 18.46 Ekspert: Overenskomst er en gratis omgang
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 18.18 Socialdemokraterne: Forrygende overenskomst
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 17.56 Fans massesørger over Whitney Houston
- Se flere nyheder
Mest læste i dag
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 02.39 Sangerinden Whitney Houston er død
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 08.54 Ulykkelige musikstjerner hylder Whitney Houston
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 12.54 Stort strømnedbrud rammer København
- 11. feb. 2012 KL. 23.47 Ekspert: Hjælp er udsigtsløs for grækerne
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 09.56 Politiet efterforsker Houstons dødsårsag
Kultur Seneste nyt
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 17.56 Fans massesørger over Whitney Houston
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 15.44 Musikekspert: Whitney var den perfekte pige
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 14.03 Svensk instruktør laver fortryllende dokumentar i sin have
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 12.06 Den naturlige soulstjerne bryder fire måneders tavshed
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 11.44 Guide: Femi-Pippi og stakkels Askepot optræder for børnene
- Se flere kultur-nyheder
Sport Seneste nyt
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 20.19 Mikkel Hansen: Vi skulle have vundet med 15
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 19.50 Contadors hjælper tæt på at sikre Riis flot triumf
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 18.42 Fløje sikrer AGK Champions League-sejr
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 17.11 Bundhold skaber sensation mod Inter
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 16.48 Györ tæver FCM-kvinder i Champions League
- Se flere sportsnyheder
IBYEN Seneste nyt
-
12. feb. 2012 KL. 18.00
Mick Øgendahl: Jeg er begyndt at drikke dåsebajere uden at flække et søm i toppen
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 14.03 Svensk instruktør laver fortryllende dokumentar i sin have
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 11.44 Guide: Femi-Pippi og stakkels Askepot optræder for børnene
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 09.00 Videokunsten blomstrer på dansk festival
- 11. feb. 2012 KL. 23.36 Genial kunstner dypper papegøje i slim
- Se flere Ibyen-nyheder
Tjek Seneste nyt
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 19.15 Med apps på smartphonen finder du billig benzin
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 15.00 Sig det med hjerter på tirsdag
- 12. feb. 2012 KL. 06.00 Ugen byder undtagelsesvist på gode oversøiske vine
- 11. feb. 2012 KL. 20.51 »Måske er vi her ikke i morgen«
- 11. feb. 2012 KL. 19.19 Hvert tolvte barn kommer til verden uden sex
- Se flere Tjek-nyheder
Latest news
- 10. feb. KL. 09.02 Man admits Greenland massacre
- 10. feb. KL. 08.38 India's president cancels DK visit
- 9. feb. KL. 18.32 SNC calls for Damascus embassy closure
- 9. feb. KL. 15.46 SF: Military mumbo jumbo
- 9. feb. KL. 11.18 Amendment to ease divorce for kids
- 9. feb. KL. 10.22 Danske Bank profit at 4bn
- 8. feb. KL. 15.26 Multiple shooting in Greenland
- 8. feb. KL. 14.43 EU countries put Tobin pressure on DK
- 8. feb. KL. 13.21 Vestas plummets on losses and changes
- 8. feb. KL. 09.08 MEMO: Army chief ordered figures changed
- 7. feb. KL. 10.02 Lennon drawings exhibition in Denmark
- 6. feb. KL. 14.17 Cold snap to continue
- 6. feb. KL. 10.17 Bankruptcies up, foreclosures down
- 6. feb. KL. 09.04 Doctors ignored metal hip warnings
- 6. feb. KL. 08.00 Pop group wins case against Liberals
Politiken guides to Copenhagen
BANGLADESH IS DROWNING
Bangla Desh is a country hard hit by the whims of a changing climate. See the
narrated series of pictures taken by Politiken’s photographer Jonathan Bjerg
Møller.
Chapter 1: Nature’s laboratory
Chapter 2: Cyclone Aila’s victims
Chapter 3: The island without men
Chapter 4: The slum a lawyer owns
Chapter 5: The town that disappeared
Chapter 6: The story of Bangla Desh
About this site
You are currently viewing the English section of Politiken.dk. The section
provides the main stories of the day from Monday to Friday and is edited by
Julian Isherwood.
Politiken is one of Denmark’s largest newspapers and has been published since 1884. The newspaper is owned by the Politiken Foundation and is part of the JP/Politikens Hus publishing group. Politiken is independent of all political parties and organisations.
Hele Danmarks Dirch...
Se eller gense de bedste klip med Dirch, oplev Nikolaj Lie Kaas fortolkning af den folkekære skuespiller, eller få den store boks med de 10 bedste Dirch Passer-film. Alt sammen til Pluspris.
Pluspriser fra 80 kr.
|
|
|
|
||||
|
Pluspris 80 kr.
Alm. pris 100 kr
|
|
Pluspris 59 kr.
Alm. pris 69 kr
|
|
Pluspris 679 kr.
Alm. pris 799 kr
|
|
Pluspris 1749 kr.
Alm. pris 2130 kr
|



















